The popular breakfast and lunch stop closed July 31, after owner Peter Fedden died in a car crash, and has remained vacant ever since.
The 29-year-old was adored by his customers, who got to know his brown hair, friendly smile and love of his community, over years of many Hungry Man Specials and double scrambled sandwiches.
Fedden was in the process of selling the business before he died, but the sale fell through. Now the business is looking for a new owner.
"We, of course, would love to see it up and running again," his mother, Kathi, said in an email.
What would you like to see happen for the future of Commack Breakfast? Tell us in the comment section below.