Parents: We'll Pay More to Save Teachers

Commack parents ask the superintendent to present the maximum 2012-13 budget allowable under the governor's tax cap Thursday night.

Commack parents have sent a clear message to school officials: Keeping teachers in the classroom is important, and they might be willing to pay more to do so.

More than 150 district residents attended Commack Superintendent Donald James' special community budget input meeting at Burr Intermediate School on Monday night. Many wanted to know how they could save the district's teachers from falling victim to $4.7 million in budget cuts for the 2012-13 school year. 

"The message I'm trying to send tonight is to go back to the Board and say at the next budget presentation what we can do, what can we propose to save our teachers' jobs. That is what is going to educate our kids," said resident Katherine Finkin. 

James has recommended a $170 million budget for the 2012-13 school  year, representing a 2.6 percent tax levy increase estimated to raise the average homeowner's taxes by $239 to $258 yearly. 

Under this proposed budget, school officials are considering laying off 40 to 60 teachers, one administrator, two secretaries, six custodians and making an additional $700,000 in cuts. The suggested cuts include the elimination of assistant coaches for 16 sports teams, elimination of the varsity swim teams, and elimination of a list of co-curricular clubs and honor societies.

"How are we firing 50 teachers, raising class sizes and not going to the bone everywhere else? This is a school district, it's about educating our children," said one man, who claimed to work in public education for 16 years. "We need to look at what a 4.1 percent budget increase means for our community." 

His comments were answered by resounding applause, and partial standing ovation.

The superintendent's proposed $170 million budget is significantly less than the district's maximum allowable within Gov. Andrew Cuomo's new property tax cap legislation. Commack school district, once calculating in exemptions and growth factors under a state formula, could raise the tax levy by 4.1 percent, or a $172 million budget, and be under the tax cap. 

Several parents said they want to know what a 4.1 percent tax levy increase would mean for Commack schools next year, specificly how many teachers and programs could be saved. James did not have those numbers readily available. 

"I don't think it's a secret, and you may not like me saying this, but there are other people who don't want us to go over percent, nevermind 3 percent or 4 percent. That is what we are hearing," the superintendnet said. 

According to the district's budget packet, handed out at various budget presentations and workshops, a 4.1 percent budget would not prevent cuts. School officials calculate it would take a 6.32 percent tax levy increase, or $174 million budget, to keep all existing programs. 

Parents suggested multiple cuts to generate further savings within the school district such as eliminating the NWEA assessments, ending the online Castle Learning program to no longer sending out printed district calendars. 

If the district were to put forth a $174 million budget, it would exceed the tax cap and would need 60 percent of voters' approval to pass. The average homeowner's yearly school taxes would increase by $580 to $626, according to the district. 

James announced March 16 that he, along with the central administration staff, will be taking. At that time, he encouraged the teachers union and other bargaining units to sit down with the board to find ways to preserve jobs, through attrition or renegotiation of contracts. 

The superintendent announced Monday that all of the school district's bargaining units have stepped forward to talk about possible renegotiation of contracts.

The Commack Board of Education will hold its next budget workshop 8p.m. Thursday at  

Tell us, would you be willing to approve a 4.1 percent tax levy increase, or $172 million budget, to prevent teacher layoffs? 

GM April 13, 2012 at 04:06 AM
A few years ago a Glenn (and maybe CSH or Garden City) voted down their budgets and forced a negotiation with teachers, etc. The Commack Board uses doomsday scenario to put fear into its residents. It does not have to be the way they present it if budget is voted down.Talk to some friends at Glenn and get some details.
Taxxed April 13, 2012 at 04:03 PM
For those helping out with the petition signatures, we can be contacted at commackvote@gmail.com. Remember, this is a signature only to get a candidate on the ballot and not a vote
Gorky April 15, 2012 at 12:59 PM
Michael, You base your info on only your home. There are different neighborhoods in this community with different values. A home bought across the street in the 1980s for around $35,000 by the owners who still live there. Just looked through 2011 at home sales in this neighborhood and the average was about 700,000. So, the increase in price on that is about 20 times purchase price. Everything depends on the neighborhood and year purchase, of course. So, you are the one twisting the numbers to suit your “vote down the budget” raison d’etre. As for all the “Italians” speaking Sicilian, how about more French. This is from a poet. His name was Rimbaud, pronounced “Rambo.” “Je meurs de soif, j’etouffe, je ne puis crier. C’est l’enfer, l’eternelle peine.” That is what it is like living here in out here in the provinces. Again, compare the tax rate in America, with that of similar developed countries. Many countries in Europe have income tax rates over 50 percent. So if you want a low tax rate, there’s Russia (13 percent), Albania (10 percent) and the Czech Republic – a great deal at 15 percent. Property taxes, income taxes, sales tax, budget deficits – it’s all the fault of teachers and administrators and everything will be resolved with a “no” vote.
chefcristo April 16, 2012 at 02:14 AM
gorky, regardless of the language you choose, the response to this year's budget vote is NO, NON, NIE, NYET........ANY WAY YOU SAY "NO" OR SPELL IT...PURE AND SIMPLE, THE ANSWER IS NO or to put it another way, ENOUGH...BASTA...that's italian (hey, even in sicilian, which, by the way may have, a somewhat different dialectical pronunciation.) you seem to have a penchant for telling people how to spend their money (lottery players) and where to live (france, albania, czech republic, russia, cuba.) some choose to spend $$ on the lottery, and most prefer to live here in commack, USA, IF ECONOMIC SITUATIONS ARE WITHIN THEIR MEANS. HIGHER TAXES (NO MATTER HOW MUCH HIGHER) ARE LITERALLY CHASING PEOPLE FROM COMMACK, INDEED FROM LONG ISLAND. i really like living here, but i have serious doubts how much longer i'll be able to afford to do so. ahhh, yes, the czech republic sounds exciting. i hope it has a lottery!
Tom Z April 16, 2012 at 02:25 AM
Gorky- what about the guy who bought that same house next door in 2008 for $850,000?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »